This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.

The original was posted on /r/boxing by /u/elgrandepolle on 2023-11-27 13:45:22.

I’m judging it based off of the fighters accomplishments in the division and not what they did outside of it.

I’d say the front runners have to be Joe Calzaghe and Andre Ward. They are the only ones who spent the majority of their career there, cleared out the division, and retired undefeated. You also got Canelo, and young James Toney and Roy Jones Jr.

It may be unpopular but I don’t rank Roy Jones Jr #1 at 168 since he’s only got 13 fights in the division although he’s clearly greater overall then everyone else.

In my opinion it’s Andre Ward. Winning the Super Six tournament is probably the most impressive accomplishment in the divisions history.

EDIT: I took GGG off I forgot he was only a mw